Friday, April 25, 2008

Blankie is Crankay!

Okay, Blankie is an inanimate wooly object, and therefore incapable of the crank. I, however, as its owner and progenitor, am totally full of the crank even after about ten hours to cool off, half a dozen fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies, two glasses of wine and a bunch of kettle chips.

I know you're just dying to know what could possibly make me *this* cranky. Well. This afternoon I was trolling around Ravelry when I stumbled across a post that included the words "the maker of this creation is doing a class at Threadbear in jun or July can’t remeber now." And he was making it in reference to MY BLANKIE! I know this for sure because he posted it in the BlankieMania group, which was founded (not by me) to discuss the blankie and how much fun people are having making it. I just about choked up a furball.

So I called the store, and yes, they are hosting a workshop in June taught by a teacher that they are bringing in from out of town. They are calling it the "Blankie" (or they were till I begged them not to). Until I brought it up, they thought that this woman had designed "The Blankie". She is their friend, and they are defending her.

I was so angry after that conversation that I was literally shaking. So then I took it a step farther and called up the woman teaching the class. Not only is she traveling to teach the class at this one store, she's apparently planning to teach it at several other stores, including her own. And she's doing so without compunction. She doesn't seem to feel bad at all about stepping on my toes at all.

It is true that many, many people have done mitered squares before me. Many people have made mitered square blankets before me - both the sewn-together and the modularly knit-together kind. I think, however, it is fair to say that I am the person who popularized the idea of large mitered-square blankets knit in small squares out of sock yarn. And I'm pretty damned sure that I'm the person who coined the term "Blankie" in reference to blankets like mine.

This teacher's blanket-in-progress looks a heck of a lot like mine, and she has it on display at the store to promote the class. Oh, except she's chosen to make hers with straight edges on the sides - something that although I haven't discussed it on the blog I do teach in my own classes on the blanket. She is stealing my share of a tiny little niche market. And there is nothing at all that I can do about it.

Even though I was the first one to knit up a blankie like mine - the first one crazy enough to collect such a variety of sock yarns and knit a queen-sized blanket on tiny needles and weave in all those ends. And then I posted about it on my blog for almost two years, proving that it could be done and that the results were worth the effort. Even though I went to the trouble - I can't copyright the idea. As long as she's writing up her own instructions she's within her rights.

The only way I can think of to do anything about this is to send out letters to every yarn store in the country offering to come there and teach the class myself. And that wouldn't stop them from hiring her or any other teacher instead of me to teach their class if they wanted to. That's just not possible since I don't have the financial resources to execute such a mailing.

And it's not even about the money. It's about the recognition, the how much fun it would be to go somewhere for a weekend and meet a bunch of enthusiastic knitters and watch their faces as they learn new tricks and gain confidence in their abilities under my tutelage. It's about the principle of if you're going to use my idea that I put out there for free as a gift that you should at least let me know ahead of time and give me credit for it. Send people to my web site to read the story of the original blankie here. And yeah, the money such as it is would be nice too.

Yeah. So I'm sitting here ranting about the blankie instead of giving you the Sunrise Circle update I was planning on. Maybe tomorrow if I can calm down a bit by then.

Oh, and since we're talking about the blankie, I thought I would share a link with you that I found a couple weeks ago. It's a blanket that looks a lot like the one I did, only her copyright date is 2005, which means that she came up with hers before I did mine, and therefore really *my* blanket looks like *hers*.

I swear, I have no recollection of ever having seen this blanket before, but I think it is great and what is even more cool is that she has a printable template for a grid you can use to color in square patterns if you want to knit a non-random blanket.

By the way, my class on my Blankie at the Yarnery in St. Paul starts on May 6. I haven't checked if there's any space left in the current session still or not, but there's always a waiting list. And if you are interested in taking a class on the Blankie - and I cover smaller scarf and shawl versions of the project as well, with various finishing options - talk to your local yarn shop about bringing me in.

26 Comments:

Anonymous Laura said...

Hi Shelly! I have a sixty three square blankie that I have been knitting for a few months. I lost it for a few of those months and recently have been knitting like crazy. I fell in love with this project when u came to Eau Claire to see the YarnHarlot. I was behind you in line and awed at ur then shawl made out of sock yarn. I thought you were ingenious. I knit in public often and at Yellow Dog Knitting in Eau Claire and people always ask about the blankie. I send them staight to your website after I boast about how u got all of ur yarn how beautiful and big your blankie is and how awsome your blog is in general. I have scribbled shellykang.com down dozens of times for people. I am so angry that someone could take credit for your project. Some who has knit on this project who knows the joy it brings to the knitters life. We in the blog world have watched ur blankie grow week after week and it has made us grow as knitters and see that all things knitting ate possible with dedication. We also believe knitters are good people and that none of our kind would do such a vicious thing. I am so sorry shelly, but I want to sincerely thank you for the gift of blankie.

4/28/2008 11:30 PM  
Blogger terrirae22 said...

Shelly... I have been reading your blog ever since finding the link from the YarnHarlot's post about burying you in sock yarn... I can't believe that someone is taking your idea nad making money from it without even giving you some credit!! I promise to never take a Blankie class from anyone other than you! :) If I could get to St. Paul next week, I would totally come and see your blankie, but it's a bit far from Dallas, TX!

Best Wishes!
-Terri

4/29/2008 12:03 AM  
Blogger AlanaMarie said...

hi! i've been reading your blog lately and i agree that i too would be cranky if someone was claiming my project. if you want any help getting the word out just say so, i live in Japan, so i cant go yarn shop to yarn shop but i've lived all over the US and know of many yarn shops that i could pass your info on to. i hope this turns around. and keep blogging i love reading!

4/29/2008 4:16 AM  
Blogger Ewe-niss said...

I saw the classes listed in Theadbear's newsletter. I looked it up and I knew it wasn't you when I saw the photo of the blankie. I wasn't interested then.:-)

Honestly - kudos to anyone making a full size blanket out of sock yarn!

4/29/2008 5:51 AM  
Blogger Ewe-niss said...

... oh and she does give you credit in her Ravelry page... does that help? :-)

4/29/2008 5:52 AM  
Blogger Rob said...

Shelley,

You're misquoting me completely for one (I didn't say we thought Meg invented it) and for two, I AM NOT THE PERSON WHO POSTED ON RAVELRY--THAT'S A RANDOM PERSON WHO'S EXCITED AND TAKING A CLASS.

Please be more specific when using HE and other non-specific pronouns, especially when attempting to lay blame.

4/29/2008 7:09 AM  
Blogger Jennu said...

Ugh! Isn't any pattern you offer for free covered under the Creative Common license? You might want to research and see if there are rules that might apply (since Copyright doesn't).

You should also have a look at this Ravelry thread thread (http://www.ravelry.com/discuss/who-knits/159636/). Many knitters and crocheters make their own Dr. Who-related patterns and share them for free. Someone stole a free pattern and was trying to sell it on eBay. In retaliation for reporting them to eBay, the seller reported the designer to the BBC for copyright violation. The BBC usually allows fan patterns as long as there's no money being made, but because the seller reported her, the BBC sent her a cease and desist request and made her take down all her free patterns.

In other words, you and Mazz should talk and vent together. Maybe form the kind of craft mafia that punishes ethical violations. :)

If nothing else, be sure to tell people in the Ravelry group what's going on. They should know it's not you teaching the classes. And a little public shaming wouldn't be out of line.

4/29/2008 7:19 AM  
Blogger Jennifer said...

I too have been reading your blog ever since the Harlot requested that we bury you in yarn. I'm appalled that someone would take your idea and try to profit from it. I'm half tempted to call her out on Ravelry---but that isn't what Ravelry is about (even though that is what people use it for...)

4/29/2008 8:14 AM  
Blogger sopranospinner said...

That is so unbelievable f'd up, I can hardly stand it. How upsetting! The only excuse would be ignorance and they don't even care that they don't even care to have an excuse! The lowness of people is always a surprise to me, but it shouldn't be by now.

Wendy

4/29/2008 9:36 AM  
Blogger Confessions of a Knitting Diva said...

I am really angry about this person cashing in on your popularity! I'm sorry for you and all of your hard work. Maybe The Harlot will get the word out on your behalf! You should get the credit for this project.

4/29/2008 9:45 AM  
Anonymous Lisa said...

I don't blame you for being cranky!! I have been reading your blog since quite early in your blankie process and am slowly building on one of my own. Like Laura, I have referred many people to your site. You were so kind to share your fun (and a great tutorial!!) with us all, and I hope this experience doesn't prevent you or others from sharing the joy of future projects. Sounds like the lady teaching this class just doesn't get it, but good for you for calling her out. I'd be beyond humiliated if I tried to pull something like that off (wouldn't dream of it) and got caught. Shame. I hope the situation works out for you in the end. Cheers!

4/29/2008 11:02 AM  
Blogger SwissKnits! said...

In my heart, I will always think of Shelly Kang and The Blankie as the Real Deal, The Original!

I'm so sorry that you have to go through this...

Michelle

4/29/2008 11:29 AM  
Blogger Ruth said...

As far as I'm concerned, you are the Blankie Mama! Period!

4/29/2008 12:11 PM  
OpenID helenkosings said...

Hi- I would like to say that I know the teacher you are talking about; she has been a long time singer in my choir. On several occasions she has brought the Afghan to knit on during rehearsal. EVERY time, she has said that this is not her idea and referred us to your website. To my knowledge, she has ****NEVER**** taken credit for "your" blankie, and on Ravelry she has her project linked to your website. She is a person of unimpeachable integrity and though I do not know how this class came to be, I can assure you this did not come about to take money or kudos from you. I am upset that you would vilify her in public in such a way.

IN MY NOt SO HUMBlE OPINION;It is not her fault AT ALL that she has been hired to teach a workshop on this afghan; how many people teach knitting using completely original ideas? Cat Bordhi is the only person I know of who has come up with some completely original ideas on her own.

Please take a deep breath and consider: Should Vivian Hoxbro have a cow because of the blankie you've made? Should the KnittingatNoon people pitch a public fit because your ideas are similar? Should every Scottish gansey knitter have a tantrum because Gladys Thompson diagrammed so many gansey stitch patterns back in the 1970's? Should Gladys Thompson blow a gasket because Beth Brown-Rinsel wrote a book about "Knitting Ganseys" and now teaches classes on it? We won't EVEN talk about mittens and mitten patterns....

You may feel your idea has been "stolen" but that is certainly not the case.

Respectfully yours,
Helen Keniston Oney

4/29/2008 1:32 PM  
Blogger Bevin said...

Dear Shelly Kang:

I have been reading your blog for over 2 years and I want you to know that your Blankie is the only Blankie in my heart.

And you're the only Blankie creator who was buried in sock yarn by the Yarn Harlot. And that means something.

xoxox,

Bevin

4/29/2008 1:38 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Shelly,

I have recently started reading your blog (after reading the Yarn Harlot's Post). I completely understand how you feel about what has happened but after reading all comments I just want to say... try and calm down... think clearly... could this possibly be a very big misunderstanding? If not that... think of this... there are so many people giving classes on so many other copyrighted patterns... I dont know much about copyrights but I cant help but wonder... is it possible for the designer to take on every proposed class for his/her project... Isn't it nice to see that others are so excited and inspired by your design that they are prepared to share it with even more? Also, as long as you are given credit... don't you get your dues? (Apparently this teacher has given you credit while making the project as well...)
It is ultimately your decision but by reading everyone's posts... you are getting all the credit that you deserve.

4/29/2008 1:52 PM  
Blogger Dianne said...

That is such a shame. You are, and will always be, the "Blankie Guru" in my book. Does it help that "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery?" Nope, I didn't think so.

4/29/2008 2:09 PM  
Anonymous Spazzmanda said...

This blows. I too have been reading your blog originally because of Blankie. One thing I learned when I started knitting socially is that knittas are craaaaaazy. At least your blog gives you the opportunity to vent, I hope you feel a tad better for it. You're entitled to your interpretation of the events (I don't think you "vilified" anyone,) so pay no mind the haters. Rock on girl.

4/29/2008 3:35 PM  
Anonymous beth said...

I think your blankie is wonderful! That's all I have to say:)

4/29/2008 5:23 PM  
Anonymous Janet from MN said...

Shelly, My advice would be to publish the "Blankie Book" before anyone else does it.

4/29/2008 6:55 PM  
Blogger Morgana said...

Shelly,

Things like what this woman is doing just upset me. Not only did you create something gorgeous, and literally slaved for years to make it, you have written up extraordinarily clear directions, and your love of the thing is clearly evident...even down to the idea of making sure all the donors of the sock yarn you used got credit...either by being used in the blankie, or being generously shared with others once you were done.
I can't say how much a fan I've been of your blog or how many times I've referred people to you, simply as a good read.
So when someone so unethically shows a pic of their blankie on Ravelry, and goes so far as to acknowledge on there that they were inspired by you AND THEN teach classes ripping off your technique pretty closely without credit, I start to doubt the inherent goodness of knitters.
In the long run, I know the majority are still good people, but its just depressing. I can't even believe creation for the project has been blatantly claimed by her.
*Sigh*
Regardless, enjoy your wine, and know that many of us are faithful readers and ethical crafters. Through your blanket I've gotten many hours of knitting joy.

4/29/2008 7:11 PM  
Anonymous jen said...

Your readers will always know who designed the REAL "Blankie!"

4/30/2008 7:12 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Honestly, I think you're making a way bigger deal out of this than it needs to be. I looked at that Ravelry link, and she credits you.

Besides, let's get real. People have been knitting mitered squares for generations and making things out of them. I've seen sweaters, vests, afghans, you name it. Do you honestly believe that you discovered some glorious untapped resource in the mitered square, that until you came along no one ever heard of mitered squares or how to make them?

Next thing you know, people will be wanting to copyright a dishcloth pattern that says, "Cast on 40 stitches, knit in garter stitch for 80 rows, bind off."

4/30/2008 10:56 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Just want to leave my pennys worth here. If you'd really wanted to make a career out of this, you should have worked harder and faster. A business takes blood, sweat, tears, TONS of time and money. You got all your yarn for free, so were very lucky. Dreams only remain that unless you do something about it. But you've invested your time on your daughters. Which is more important? Money and fame, or ....... You work it out.

5/01/2008 11:54 AM  
Anonymous rosesmama said...

It seems there are some anonymous people who 1) are not courageous enough to leave their name(s) and 2) don't seem to get the point that Shelly has been using the name Blankie for all these years, been diligent and made very popular by this diligence, and the Mitered Square Afghan person should not just give credit on Ravelry but in the title of her classes if she has any integrity. A simple "Mitered Square Afghan as popularized by Shelly Kang" might suffice. If she had integrity, why didn't she contact Shelly to let her know what she was doing and that she wanted to use the name Blankie? I don't particularly like mitered squares, have never made one, and have no intentions of making one, let alone hundreds, but I do respect stunning feats of craft, and Shelly's Blankie is one, and she should be given credit where it is due.

5/02/2008 5:03 AM  
Anonymous jeff said...

I am 43 yrs old and have been using the term blankie since I could talk....it's hardly a new word now is it!!!!

5/10/2008 7:05 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home